Why Reason Isn’t Enough

If you can’t pay your mortgage, don’t feel bad about defaulting and walking away. After all, it was the greedy mortgage brokers and banks who induced you into a mortgage you couldn’t afford. They made their money, now they should take their medicine.

No, wait. You had a choice. Nobody put a gun to your head and said, “Buy this house or else.” Besides, if you default, it’s not just the bank who pays but the rest of the society through more taxes for bailouts and higher interest rates.

Which argument appeals to you? Take your pick. Both are based on reason. You could choose either one and sound reasonable. Continue reading “Why Reason Isn’t Enough”

On The Casey Anthony Verdict

It seems the whole nation is angry over the Casey Anthony verdict.

If you are a citizen of the kingdom of God and you are struggling with the same feelings, you may want to reconsider.

The Old Testament law required two witnesses to a capital crime. (Deuteronomy 17:6).  To serve as a witness, the individual could not be guilty of the crime for which they served as a witness.  (Deuteronomy 19:15). Additionally, one of the witnesses had to be willing to initiate the execution. (Deuteronomy 17:7).

These strict procedural requirements would, for example, prohibit the modern practice of relying on coconspirator testimony to obtain convictions, and make conviction a practical impossibility where the witnesses were, as some believe was the case in the Casey Anthony trial, family members. Continue reading “On The Casey Anthony Verdict”

On Torture

There has been much talk about torture since Osama Bin Laden’s death.

Those who advocate for torture cite Bin Laden’s death as evidence that torture works, while those against deny that torture led to the discovery of Bin Laden’s lair. Both sides are missing the point.

It doesn’t matter whether torture led to Bin Laden’s death. Torture  obviously works, if by “works” we mean it makes people more likely to give up information they would not otherwise disclose. But that’s not the issue.

We could institute the death penalty for parking violations and it would make double parking a thing of the past. But just because something works doesn’t make it right. The issue is whether torture is moral, and, if so, in what circumstances. Continue reading “On Torture”

Are You Really An Absolutist?

If you are a Christian, I have a question for you: Are you an absolutist?

Don’t answer yet because I have another question for you first: Is it ever moral for a Christian to lie?

If your answer is “No,” you are an absolutist, but you have a problem because the Bible suggests that sometimes lying is not only moral but a heroic act of faith.

I’m referring, of course, to the story of Rahab. (Joshua 2; Joshua 6:17; Hebrews 11:31; James 2:25).

What if a loved one had a heart attack and you were rushing him or her to the emergency room. Every minute counts. Do you run the red light? If you are an absolutist you have a problem. If you are a “graded absolutist,” no problem. Continue reading “Are You Really An Absolutist?”

Man Bites Dog

Maybe you saw this headline earlier this year, “Man Gets 15 Years After Trying to Break Into Jail.”

Yes, you read it right, “break into jail.”  If you don’t believe me, you can read it here.

Dude was on probation for manslaughter, but three days after being released returns to jail and begs deputies to take him back into the jail because he feared retaliation from the victim’s family.  When he was refused entry he tried to reenter the jail by climbing a 12-foot high fence.  He was caught, convicted of trespassing and resisting an officer and was sentenced to 15 years for violating his probation.  It goes without saying this was probably the stiffest sentence ever given to anyone for attempting to break back into jail.

This story strikes me as odd, which, according to G.K. Chesterton, is a good thing since “…oddities only strike ordinary people.  Odditities do not strike odd people.”  This story also strikes me as interesting because it never could have happened under Old Testament law.  Here’s why.

First, there were no jails or prisons under the Old Testament law. It’s true.  It’s not because there weren’t criminals.  It’s just that criminals were required to make restitution or were sold into bond service to pay restitution (to the victim, not to the State), or, if the victim did not choose a ransom or ransom was not available under the law and it was a capital crime, they were given the ultimate earthly punishment.

Second, the Lord anticipated the situation encountered by our jailbreaker and set up cities of refuge for those guilty of manslaughter so they could avoid victims’ vengeful relatives who might have thoughts of helping the manslayer into the grave. See Numbers 35:9-12.

So what is the point?  I don’t know.  I’m just saying, it strikes me as odd. GS